Somewhere in the East End of London, a woman steps into a tiled shop and orders what her grandmother used to order. The dish arrives in thirty seconds. It costs a few pounds. And it has not changed once in over two hundred years.
That dish is pie and mash. And it has been keeping London fed for over two hundred years.
What Is Pie and Mash?
The dish itself is simple. A minced beef pie — usually small but dense, with short-crust pastry — sits in a pool of “liquor.” Beside it is a generous scoop of creamy mashed potato.
The liquor confuses every first-timer. It contains no alcohol. The name comes from the water used to cook jellied eels — a dish once served alongside pie and mash in most shops. The sauce is made from stock, flour, and fresh parsley. It is thin. It is vivid green. It is poured over everything before the plate reaches you.
In some shops you can still order jellied eels on the side. In most, few people under sixty do. But the liquor stays. It soaks into the mash and pastry until the whole dish tastes as though it was meant to be eaten together, which it was.
Where the Tradition Came From
Pie and mash grew out of the street food culture of Victorian London. The Thames was full of eels, and eel sellers worked the markets and riverside fairs of the East End. As London expanded and the city’s working class grew, permanent shops replaced the stalls.
By the 1850s, the pie and mash shop had become a fixture of South and East London. The format was consistent across all of them: long, white-tiled rooms with marble-topped tables and wooden booths, built to move customers through quickly and cheaply. Nothing decorative on the walls except mirrors. No printed menus. Just the one dish, served hot.
The families who ran these shops passed them down through generations. The recipes did not change. The interiors did not change. In a city that has rebuilt itself countless times since the Victorian era, the pie and mash shop is one of the few things that simply refused to move.
The Shops That Are Still Open
A handful of shops have served pie and mash continuously for over a century.
Manze’s in Peckham opened in 1902. The original marble countertops are still there. The white-tiled walls still gleam. On a Saturday morning it fills with a mixture of families who have been coming for decades and visitors who found it on a food blog. Both wait the same amount of time. Both pay the same price.
Goddards at Greenwich has been open since 1890. Its current home in Greenwich town centre — recognisable by the dark green shopfront and the “Pie and Mash” sign above the door — draws queues on weekends. The menu has not expanded. The prices remain among the lowest you will find for a hot meal anywhere in London.
Castle’s on Chapel Street in Islington has records tracing back to the early 1800s. It operates today as it always has — no website, no delivery service, no seasonal specials. Just pie and mash and liquor, served in the shop, eaten at the counter.
These shops are not restaurants pretending to look old. They simply never stopped.
What the Liquor Actually Is
The liquor divides people at first. Then it usually wins them over.
It is made from water — originally from cooking the eels — thickened with cornflour and finished with fresh parsley. The result is a thin, bright green sauce with a faint savouriness and a clean, herby finish. Nothing like gravy. Nothing like anything else you have tasted.
The proportions vary from shop to shop, and regulars take this seriously. Someone who grew up eating at one shop will quietly dismiss another’s liquor as too thick or too thin. The debate is completely serious and entirely affectionate.
Malt vinegar is the standard accompaniment, splashed liberally over the mash. In some shops, chilli vinegar is also on the counter. Both are free. Both are expected.
Why It Survived Everything
Pie and mash has no celebrity chef endorsements. There are no Michelin stars. No food trend has claimed it and moved on.
What it has is loyalty — the kind that builds across generations and does not break easily.
For much of the twentieth century, pie and mash shops served as gathering places for working families. Eating at the counter, seeing the same faces, sitting in the same booth — it became part of a weekly rhythm. The shops survived the Blitz, post-war redevelopment, and the arrival of fast food chains. Each time, the regulars came back.
The Victorian East End that shaped this tradition has changed dramatically over the decades. But the pie shops at its edges have mostly held on, still serving the same dish to people whose connection to them spans entire lifetimes.
How to Find a Pie and Mash Shop
If you are planning a trip to London, a pie and mash shop belongs on your list alongside the museums and the parks. Not as a novelty. As a genuine slice of the city’s history.
Goddards at Greenwich is the easiest starting point. It is a short walk from the Cutty Sark DLR station and is open every day of the week. Order the pie and mash with liquor. Add malt vinegar. Sit at the counter if a stool is free.
For a more traditional experience, Manze’s in Peckham is worth the journey south. The shop does not advertise. It does not need to. It has been full at lunchtime for over a hundred years.
Go hungry. Eat slowly. Pay the few pounds it costs. And leave knowing you have tasted something that has survived everything London has thrown at it for two centuries.
Join 3,000+ London Lovers
Every week, get London’s hidden gems, culture, and travel inspiration — straight to your inbox.
Love more? Join 65,000 Ireland lovers → · Join 43,000 Scotland lovers → · Join 30,000 Italy lovers →
Free forever · One email per week · Unsubscribe anytime
London has always found ways to feed itself through hard times. Pie and mash was never fashionable and never meant to be. It was built for people who needed to eat, not to impress. Two hundred years later, it is still doing exactly that.